Appendix D to Subpart C of Part 197 - Sampling and Analytical Methods for Benzene Monitoring - Measurement Procedures
46:7.0.1.5.30.3.75.18.4 : Appendix D
Appendix D to Subpart C of Part 197 - Sampling and Analytical
Methods for Benzene Monitoring - Measurement Procedures
Measurements taken for the purpose of determining employee
exposure to benzene are best taken so that the representative
average eight-hour exposure may be determined from a single
eight-hour sample or two four-hour samples. Short-time interval
samples (or grab samples) may also be used to determine average
exposure level if a minimum of five measurements are taken in a
random manner over the eight-hour work shift. In random sampling,
any portion of the work shift has the same chance of being sampled
as any other. The arithmetic average of all random samples taken on
one work shift is an estimate of an employee's average level of
exposure for that work shift. Air samples should be taken in the
employee's breathing zone (i.e., air that would most nearly
represent that inhaled by the employee). Sampling and analysis must
be performed with procedures meeting the requirements of 46 CFR
part 197, subpart C.
There are a number of methods available for monitoring employee
exposures to benzene. The sampling and analysis may be performed by
collection of the benzene vapor on charcoal adsorption tubes, with
subsequent chemical analysis by gas chromatography. Sampling and
analysis also may be performed by portable direct reading
instruments, real-time continuous monitoring systems, passive
dosimeters, or other suitable methods. The employer is required to
select a monitoring method which meets the accuracy and precision
requirements of 46 CFR 197.540(a)(6) for the weather conditions
expected. Section 197.540(a)(6) requires that monitoring must have
an accuracy, to a 95 percent confidence level, of not less than
plus or minus 25 percent for concentrations of benzene greater than
or equal to 0.5 ppm.
In developing the following analytical procedures, the OSHA
Laboratory modified NIOSH Method S311 and evaluated it at a benzene
air concentration of one ppm. A procedure for determining the
benzene concentration in bulk material samples was also evaluated.
This work, as reported in OSHA Laboratory Method No. 12, includes
the following two analytical procedures:
I. OSHA Method 12 for Air Samples
Analyte: Benzene.
Matrix: Air.
Procedure: Adsorption on charcoal, desorption with carbon
disulfide, analysis by gas chromatograph.
Detection limit: 0.04 ppm.
Recommended air volume and sampling rate: 10 liter at 0.2
liter/min.
1. Principle of the method
1.1. A known volume of air is drawn through a charcoal tube to
trap the organic vapors present.
1.2. The charcoal in the tube is transferred to a small,
stoppered vial and the analyte is desorbed with carbon
disulfide.
1.3. An aliquot of the desorbed sample is injected into a gas
chromatograph.
1.4. The area of the resulting peak is determined and compared
with areas obtained from standards.
2. Advantages and disadvantages of the method
2.1. The sampling device is small, portable, and involves no
liquids. Interferences are minimal and most of those which do occur
can be eliminated by altering chromatographic conditions. The
samples are analyzed by means of a quick, instrumental method.
2.2. The amount of sample which can be taken is limited by the
number of milligrams that the tube will hold before overloading.
When the sample value obtained for the backup section of the
charcoal tube exceeds 25 percent of that found on the front
section, the possibility of sample loss exists.
3. Apparatus
3.1. A calibrated personal sampling pump having a flow that can
be determined within ±five percent at the recommended flow
rate.
3.2. Charcoal tubes: Glass with both ends flame sealed, seven cm
long with a six mm O.D. and a four mm I.D., containing two sections
of 20/40 mesh activated charcoal separated by a two mm portion of
urethane foam. The activated charcoal is prepared from coconut
shells and is fired at 600 °C before packing. The adsorbing section
contains 100 mg of charcoal and the back-up section 50 mg. A three
mm portion of urethane foam is placed between the outlet end of the
tube and the back-up section. A plug of silanized glass wool is
placed in front of the adsorbing section. The pressure drop across
the tube must be less than one inch of mercury at a flow rate of
one liter per minute.
3.3. Gas chromatograph equipped with a flame ionization
detector.
3.4. Column (10 ft. × 1/8 in. stainless steel) packed with
80/100 Supelcoport coated with 20 percent SP 2100 and 0.1 percent
CW 1500.
3.5. An electronic integrator or some other suitable method for
measuring peak area.
3.6. Two-milliliter sample vials with Teflon-lined caps.
3.7. Microliter syringes: ten microliter (ten µl) syringe, and
other convenient sizes for making standards. One µl syringe for
sample injections.
3.8. Pipets: 1.0 ml delivery pipets.
3.9. Volumetric flasks: convenient sizes for making standard
solutions.
4. Reagents
4.1. Chromatographic quality carbon disulfide (CS2). Most
commercially available carbon disulfide contains a trace of benzene
which must be removed. It can be removed with the following
procedure. Heat, under reflux for two to three hours, 500 ml of
carbon disulfide, ten ml concentrated sulfuric acid, and five drops
of concentrated nitric acid. The benzene is converted to
nitrobenzene. The carbon disulfide layer is removed, dried with
anhydrous sodium sulfate, and distilled. The recovered carbon
disulfide should be benzene free. (It has recently been determined
that benzene can also be removed by passing the carbon disulfide
through a 13x molecular sieve).
4.2. Benzene, reagent grade.
4.3. p-Cymene, reagent grade, (internal standard).
4.4. Desorbing reagent. The desorbing reagent is prepared by
adding 0.05 ml of p-cymene per milliliter of carbon disulfide. (The
internal standard offers a convenient means correcting analytical
response for slight inconsistencies in the size of sample
injections. If the external standard technique is preferred, the
internal standard can be eliminated.)
4.5. Purified GC grade helium, hydrogen, and air.
5. Procedure
5.1. Cleaning of equipment. All glassware used for the
laboratory analysis should be properly cleaned and free of organics
which could interfere in the analysis.
5.2. Calibration of personal pumps. Each pump must be calibrated
with a representative charcoal tube in the line.
5.3. Collection and shipping of samples.
5.3.1. Immediately before sampling, break the ends of the tube
to provide an opening at least one-half the internal diameter of
the tube (two mm).
5.3.2. The smaller section of the charcoal is used as the backup
and should be placed nearest the sampling pump.
5.3.3. The charcoal tube should be placed in a vertical position
during sampling to minimize channeling through the charcoal.
5.3.4. Air being sampled should not be passed through any hose
or tubing before entering the charcoal tube.
5.3.5. A sample size of 10 liters is recommended. Sample at a
flow rate of approximately 0.2 liters per minute. The flow rate
should be known with an accuracy of at least ±five percent.
5.3.6. The charcoal tubes should be capped with the supplied
plastic caps immediately after sampling.
5.3.7. Submit at least one blank tube (a charcoal tube subjected
to the same handling procedures, without having any air drawn
through it) with each set of samples.
5.3.8. Take necessary shipping and packing precautions to
minimize breakage of samples.
5.4. Analysis of samples.
5.4.1. Preparation of samples. In preparation for analysis, each
charcoal tube is scored with a file in front of the first section
of charcoal and broken open. The glass wool is removed and
discarded. The charcoal in the first (larger) section is
transferred to a two ml vial. The separating section of foam is
removed and discarded and the second section is transferred to
another capped vial. These two sections are analyzed
separately.
5.4.2. Desorption of samples. Before analysis, 1.0 ml of
desorbing solution is pipetted into each sample container. The
desorbing solution consists of 0.05 µl internal standard per
milliliter of carbon disulfide. The sample vials are capped as soon
as the solvent is added. Desorption should be done for 30 minutes
with occasional shaking.
5.4.3. GC conditions. Typical operating conditions for the gas
chromatograph are as follows:
1. 30 ml/min (60 psig) helium carrier gas flow.
2. 30 ml/min (40 psig) hydrogen gas flow to detector.
3. 240 ml/min (40 psig) air flow to detector.
4. 150 °C injector temperature.
5. 250 °C detector temperature.
6. 100 °C column temperature.
5.4.4. Injection size. One µl.
5.4.5. Measurement of area. The peak areas are measured by an
electronic integrator or some other suitable form of area
measurement.
5.4.6. An internal standard procedure is used. The integrator is
calibrated to report results in ppm for a 10 liter air sample after
correction for desorption efficiency.
5.5. Determination of desorption efficiency.
5.5.1. Importance of determination. The desorption efficiency of
a particular compound may vary from one laboratory to another and
from one lot of chemical to another. Thus, it is necessary to
determine, at least once, the percentage of the specific compound
that is removed in the desorption process, provided the same batch
of charcoal is used.
5.5.2. Procedure for determining desorption efficiency. The
reference portion of the charcoal tube is removed. To the remaining
portion, amounts representing 0.5X, 1X, and 2X (X represents target
concentration) based on a 10 liter air sample, are injected into
several tubes at each level. Dilutions of benzene with carbon
disulfide are made to allow injection of measurable quantities.
These tubes are then allowed to equilibrate at least overnight.
Following equilibration, they are analyzed following the same
procedure as the samples. Desorption efficiency is determined by
dividing the amount of benzene found by amount spiked on the
tube.
6. Calibration and standards
A series of standards varying in concentration over the range of
interest is prepared and analyzed under the same GC conditions that
will be used on the samples. A calibration curve is prepared by
plotting concentration (µg/ml) versus peak area.
7. Calculations
Benzene air concentration can be calculated from the following
equation:
mg/m 3 = (A)(B)/(C)(D) Where: A=µg/ml benzene, obtained from the
calibration curve; B = desorption volume (one ml); C = liters of
air sampled; and D = desorption efficiency.
The concentration in mg/m 3 can be converted to ppm (at 25° and
760 mm) with following equation:
ppm = (mg/m 3)(24.46)/(78.11). Where: 24.46 = molar volume of an
ideal gas 25 °C and 760 mm; and 78.11 = molecular weight of
benzene. 8. Backup data
8.1 Detection limit - Air Samples. The detection limit for the
analytical procedure is 1.28 ng with a coefficient of variation of
0.023 at this level. This would be equivalent to an air
concentration of 0.04 ppm for a 10 liter air sample. This amount
provided a chromatographic peak that could be identifiable in the
presence of possible interferences. The detection limit data were
obtained by making one µl injections of a 1.283 µg/ml standard.
Injection |
Area count |
|
1 |
655.4 |
|
2 |
617.5 |
|
3 |
662.0 |
X = 640.2 |
4 |
641.1 |
SD = 14.9 |
5 |
636.4 |
CV = 0.023 |
6 |
629.2 |
|
8.2 Pooled coefficient of variation - Air Samples. The pooled
coefficient of variation for the analytical procedure was
determined by one µl replicate injections of analytical standards.
The standards were 16.04, 32.08, and 64.16 µg/ml, which are
equivalent to 0.5, 1.0, and 2.0 ppm for a 10 liter air sample
respectively.
8.3 Storage data - Air Samples. Samples were generated at 1.03
ppm benzene at 80% relative humidity, 22 °C, and 643 mm. All
samples were taken for 50 minutes at 0.2 liters/min. Six samples
were analyzed immediately and the rest of the samples were divided
into two groups by fifteen samples each. One group was stored at
refrigerated temperature of −25 °C and the other group was stored
at ambient temperature (approximately 23 °C). These samples were
analyzed over a period of fifteen days. The results are tabulated
below.
Injection |
Area counts |
0.5 ppm |
1.0 ppm |
2.0 ppm |
1 |
3996.5 |
8130.2 |
16481 |
2 |
4059.4 |
8235.6 |
16493 |
3 |
4052.0 |
8307.9 |
16535 |
4 |
4027.2 |
8263.2 |
16609 |
5 |
4046.8 |
8291.1 |
16552 |
6 |
4137.9 |
8288.8 |
16618 |
X= |
4053.3 |
8254.0 |
16548.3 |
SD= |
47.2 |
62.5 |
57.1 |
CV= |
0.0116 |
0.0076 |
0.0034 |
CV = 0.008 |
|
|
|
Day analyzed |
Refrigerated |
Ambient |
|
|
|
|
|
|
0 |
97.4 |
98.7 |
98.9 |
97.4 |
98.7 |
98.9 |
0 |
97.1 |
100.6 |
100.9 |
97.1 |
100.6 |
100.9 |
2 |
95.8 |
96.4 |
95.4 |
95.4 |
96.6 |
96.9 |
5 |
93.9 |
93.7 |
92.4 |
92.4 |
94.3 |
94.1 |
9 |
93.6 |
95.5 |
94.6 |
95.2 |
95.6 |
96.6 |
13 |
94.3 |
95.3 |
93.7 |
91.0 |
95.0 |
94.6 |
15 |
96.8 |
95.8 |
94.2 |
92.9 |
96.3 |
95.9 |
8.4 Desorption data. Samples were prepared by injecting liquid
benzene onto the A section of charcoal tubes. Samples were prepared
that would be equivalent to 0.5, 1.0, and 2.0 ppm for a 10 liter
air sample.
Sample |
0.5 ppm |
1.0 ppm |
2.0 ppm |
1 |
99.4 |
98.8 |
99.5 |
2 |
99.5 |
98.7 |
99.7 |
3 |
99.2 |
98.6 |
99.8 |
4 |
99.4 |
99.1 |
100.0 |
5 |
99.2 |
99.0 |
99.7 |
6 |
99.8 |
99.1 |
99.9 |
X= |
99.4 |
98.9 |
99.8 |
SD= |
0.22 |
0.21 |
0.18 |
C V= |
0.0022 |
0.0021 |
0.0018 |
X = 99.4 |
|
|
|
8.5 Carbon disulfide. Carbon disulfide from a number of sources
was analyzed for benzene contamination. The results are given in
the following table. The benzene contaminant can be removed with
the procedures given in section I.4.1.
Sample |
µg Benzene/ml |
ppm equivalent (for 10 liter
air sample) |
ALDRICH Lot
83017 |
4.20 |
0.13 |
BAKER Lot
720364 |
1.01 |
0.03 |
BAKER Lot
822351 |
1.01 |
0.03 |
Malinkrodt Lot
WEMP |
1.74 |
0.05 |
Malinkrodt Lot
WDSJ |
5.65 |
0.18 |
Malinkrodt Lot
WHGA |
2.90 |
0.09 |
Treated CS2 |
|
|
II. OSHA Laboratory Method No. 12 for Bulk Samples
Analyte: Benzene.
Matrix: Bulk Samples.
Procedure: Bulk samples are analyzed directly by high
performance liquid chromatography (HPLC).
Detection limits: 0.01% by volume.
1. Principle of the method
1.1. An aliquot of the bulk sample to be analyzed is injected
into a liquid chromatograph.
1.2. The peak area for benzene is determined and compared to
areas obtained from standards.
2. Advantages and disadvantages of the method
2.1. The analytical procedure is quick, sensitive, and
reproducible.
2.2. Reanalysis of samples is possible.
2.3. Interferences can be circumvented by proper selection of
HPLC parameters.
2.4. Samples must be free of any particulates that may clog the
capillary tubing in the liquid chromatograph. This may require
distilling the sample or clarifying with a clarification kit.
3. Apparatus
3.1. Liquid chromatograph equipped with a UV detector.
3.2. HPLC Column that will separate benzene from other
components in the bulk sample being analyzed. The column used for
validation studies was a Waters uBondapack C18, 30 cm × 3.9 mm.
3.3. A clarification kit to remove any particulates in the bulk
if necessary.
3.4. A micro-distillation apparatus to distill any samples if
necessary.
3.5. An electronic integrator or some other suitable method of
measuring peak areas.
3.6. Microliter syringes - ten µl syringe and other convenient
sizes for making standards. 10 µl syringe for sample
injections.
3.7. Volumetric flasks, five ml and other convenient sizes for
preparing standards and making dilutions.
4. Reagents
4.1. Benzene, reagent grade.
4.2. HPLC grade water, methyl alcohol, and isopropyl
alcohol.
5. Collection and shipment of samples
5.1. Samples should be transported in glass containers with
Teflon-lined caps.
5.2. Samples should not be put in the same container used for
air samples
6. Analysis of samples
6.1. Sample preparation. If necessary, the samples are distilled
or clarified. Samples are analyzed undiluted. If the benzene
concentration is out of the working range, suitable dilutions are
made with isopropyl alcohol.
6.2. HPLC conditions. The typical operating conditions for the
high performance liquid chromatograph are:
6.2.1. Mobile phase - Methyl alcohol/water, 50/50.
6.2.2. Analytical wavelength - 254 nm.
6.2.3. Injection size - 10 µl.
6.3. Measurement of peak area and calibration. Peak areas are
measured by an integrator or other suitable means. The integrator
is calibrated to report results in % benzene by volume.
7. Calculations
Because the integrator is programmed to report results in %
benzene by volume in an undiluted sample, the following equation is
used: % Benzene by Volume = A × B.
Where: A = % by volume on report. B = Dilution Factor. (B = one
for undiluted sample).
8. Backup data
8.1. Detection limit - Bulk Samples. The detection limit for the
analytical procedure for bulk samples is 0.88 µg, with a
coefficient of variation of 0.019 at this level. This amount
provided a chromatographic peak that could be identifiable in the
presence of possible interferences. The detection limit date were
obtained by making ten µl injections of a 0.10% by volume
standard.
Injection |
Area Count |
|
1 |
45386 |
|
2 |
44214 |
|
3 |
43822 |
X = 44040.1 |
4 |
44062 |
SD = 852.5 |
6 |
42724 |
CV = 0.019 |
8.2. Pooled coefficient of variation - Bulk Samples. The pooled
coefficient of variation for the analytical procedure was
determined by 50 µl replicate injections of analytical standards.
The standards were 0.01, 0.02, 0.04, 0.10, 1.0, and 2.0% benzene by
volume.
Injection # |
0.01 |
0.02 |
0.04 |
0.10 |
1.0 |
2.0 |
1 |
45386 |
84737 |
166097 |
448497 |
4395380 |
9339150 |
2 |
44241 |
84300 |
170832 |
441299 |
4590800 |
9484900 |
3 |
43822 |
83835 |
164160 |
443719 |
4593200 |
9557580 |
4 |
44062 |
84381 |
164445 |
444842 |
4642350 |
9677060 |
5 |
44006 |
83012 |
168398 |
442564 |
4646430 |
9766240 |
6 |
42724 |
81957 |
173002 |
443975 |
4646260 |
|
X= |
44040.1 |
83703.6 |
167872 |
444149 |
4585767 |
9564986 |
SD= |
852.5 |
1042.2 |
3589.8 |
2459.1 |
96839.3 |
166233 |
CV= |
0.0194 |
0.0125 |
0.0213 |
0.0055 |
0.0211 |
0.0174 |
CV = 0.017 |
|
|
|
|
|
|