Appendix B to Part 202 - “Best Edition” of Published Copyrighted Works for the Collections of the Library of Congress
37:1.0.2.6.3.0.228.22.4 : Appendix B
Appendix B to Part 202 - “Best Edition” of Published Copyrighted
Works for the Collections of the Library of Congress
a. The copyright law (title 17, United States Code) requires
that copies or phonorecords deposited in the Copyright Office be of
the “best edition” of the work. The law states that “The ‘best
edition’ of a work is the edition, published in the United States
at any time before the date of deposit, that the Library of
Congress determines to be most suitable for its purposes.” (For
works first published only in a country other than the United
States, the law requires the deposit of the work as first
published.)
b. When two or more editions of the same version of a work have
been published, the one of the highest quality is generally
considered to be the best edition. In judging quality, the Library
of Congress will adhere to the criteria set forth below in all but
exceptional circumstances.
c. Where differences between editions represent variations in
copyrightable content, each edition is a separate version and “best
edition” standards based on such differences do not apply. Each
such version is a separate work for the purpose of the copyright
law.
d. The criteria to be applied in determining the best edition of
each of several types of material are listed below in descending
order of importance. In deciding between two editions, a
criterion-by-criterion comparison should be made. The edition which
first fails to satisfy a criterion is to be considered of inferior
quality and will not be an acceptable deposit. Example: If a
comparison is made between two hardbound editions of a book, one a
trade edition printed on acid-free paper, and the other a specially
bound edition printed on average paper, the former will be the best
edition because the type of paper is a more important criterion
than the binding.
e. Under regulations of the Copyright Office, potential
depositors may request authorization to deposit copies or
phonorecords of other than the best edition of a specific work
(e.g., a microform rather than a printed edition of a serial), by
requesting “special relief” from the deposit requirements. All
requests for special relief should be in writing and should state
the reason(s) why the applicant cannot send the required deposit
and what the applicant wishes to submit instead of the required
deposit.
I. Printed Textual Matter
A. Paper, Binding, and Packaging:
1. Archival-quality rather than less-permanent paper.
2. Hard cover rather than soft cover.
3. Library binding rather than commercial binding.
4. Trade edition rather than book club edition.
5. Sewn rather than glue-only binding.
6. Sewn or glued rather than stapled or spiral-bound.
7. Stapled rather than spiral-bound or plastic-bound.
8. Bound rather than looseleaf, except when future looseleaf
insertions are to be issued. In the case of looseleaf materials,
this includes the submission of all binders and indexes when they
are part of the unit as published and offered for sale or
distribution. Additionally, the regular and timely receipt of all
appropriate looseleaf updates, supplements, and releases including
supplemental binders issued to handle these expanded versions, is
part of the requirement to properly maintain these
publications.
9. Slip-cased rather than nonslip-cased.
10. With protective folders rather than without (for
broadsides).
11. Rolled rather than folded (for broadsides).
12. With protective coatings rather than without (except
broadsides, which should not be coated).
B. Rarity:
1. Special limited edition having the greatest number of special
features.
2. Other limited edition rather than trade edition.
3. Special binding rather than trade binding.
C. Illustrations:
1. Illustrated rather than unillustrated.
2. Illustrations in color rather than black and white.
D. Special Features:
1. With thumb notches or index tabs rather than without.
2. With aids to use such as overlays and magnifiers rather than
without.
E. Size:
1. Larger rather than smaller sizes. (Except that large-type
editions for the partially-sighted are not required in place of
editions employing type of more conventional size.)
II. Photographs
A. Size and finish, in descending order of preference:
1. The most widely distributed edition.
2. 8 × 10-inch glossy print.
3. Other size or finish.
B. Unmounted rather than mounted.
C. Archival-quality rather than less-permanent paper stock or
printing process.
III. Motion Pictures
Film medium is considered a better quality than any other
medium. The formats under “film” and “video formats” are listed in
descending order of preference:
A. Film:
1. Preprint material, by special arrangement.
2. 70 mm positive print, if original production negative is
greater than 35 mm.
3. 35 mm positive prints.
4. 16 mm positive prints.
B. Video Formats:
1. Betacam SP.
2. Digital Beta (Digibeta).
3. DVD.
4. VHS Cassette.
IV. Other Graphic Matter
A. Paper and Printing:
1. Archival quality rather than less-permanent paper.
2. Color rather than black and white.
B. Size and Content:
1. Larger rather than smaller size.
2. In the case of cartographic works, editions with the greatest
amount of information rather than those with less detail.
C. Rarity:
1. The most widely distributed edition rather than one of
limited distribution.
2. In the case of a work published only in a limited, numbered
edition, one copy outside the numbered series but otherwise
identical.
3. A photographic reproduction of the original, by special
arrangement only.
D. Text and Other Materials:
1. Works with annotations, accompanying tabular or textual
matter, or other interpretative aids rather than those without
them.
E. Binding and Packaging:
1. Bound rather than unbound.
2. If editions have different binding, apply the criteria in
I.A.2-I.A.7, above.
3. Rolled rather than folded.
4. With protective coatings rather than without.
V. Phonorecords
A. Compact digital disc rather than a vinyl disc.
B. Vinyl disc rather than tape.
C. With special enclosures rather than without.
D. Open-reel rather than cartridge.
E. Cartridge rather than cassette.
F. Quadraphonic rather than stereophonic.
G. True stereophonic rather than monaural.
H. Monaural rather than electronically rechanneled stereo.
VI. Musical Compositions
A. Fullness of Score:
1. Vocal music:
a. With orchestral accompaniment:
i. Full score and parts, if any, rather than conductor's score
and parts, if any. (In cases of compositions published only by
rental, lease, or lending, this requirement is reduced to full
score only.)
ii. Conductor's score and parts, if any, rather than condensed
score and parts, if any. (In cases of compositions published only
by rental, lease, or lending, this requirement is reduced to
conductor's score only.)
b. Unaccompanied: Open score (each part on separate staff)
rather than closed score (all parts condensed to two staves).
2. Instrumental music:
a. Full score and parts, if any, rather than conductor's score
and parts, if any. (In cases of compositions published only by
rental, lease, or lending, this requirement is reduced to full
score only.)
b. Conductor's score and parts, if any, rather than condensed
score and parts, if any. (In cases of compositions published only
by rental, lease, or lending, this requirement is reduced to
conductor's score only.)
B. Printing and Paper:
1. Archival-quality rather than less-permanent paper.
C. Binding and Packaging:
1. Special limited editions rather than trade editions.
2. Bound rather than unbound.
3. If editions have different binding, apply the criteria in
I.A.2-I.A.12, above.
4. With protective folders rather than without.
VII. Microforms
A. Related Materials:
1. With indexes, study guides, or other printed matter rather
than without.
B. Permanence and Appearance:
1. Silver halide rather than any other emulsion.
2. Positive rather than negative.
3. Color rather than black and white.
C. Format (newspapers and newspaper-formatted serials):
1. Reel microfilm rather than any other microform.
D. Format (all other materials):
1. Microfiche rather than reel microfilm.
2. Reel microfilm rather than microform cassetes.
3. Microfilm cassettes rather than micro-opaque prints.
E. Size:
1. 35 mm rather than 16 mm.
VIII. Machine-Readable Copies
A. Computer Programs:
1. With documents and other accompanying material rather than
without.
2. Not copy-protected rather than copy-protected (if
copy-protected then with a backup copy of the disk(s)).
3. Format:
a. PC-DOS or MS-DOS (or other IBM compatible formats, such as
XENIX):
(i) 5 1/4″ Diskette(s).
(ii) 3 1/2″ Diskette(s).
(iii) Optical media, such as CD-ROM - best edition should adhere
to prevailing NISO standards.
b. Apple Macintosh:
(i) 3 1/2″ Diskette(s).
(ii) Optical media, such as CD-ROM - best edition should adhere
to prevailing NISO standards.
B. Computerized Information Works, Including Statistical
Compendia, Serials, or Reference Works:
1. With documentation and other accompanying material rather
than without.
2. With best edition of accompanying program rather than
without.
3. Not copy-protected rather than copy-protected (if
copy-protected then with a backup copy of the disk(s)).
4. Format:
a. PC-DOS or MS-DOS (or other IBM compatible formats, such as
XENIX):
(i) Optical media, such as CD-ROM - best edition should adhere
to prevailing NISO standards.
(ii) 5 1/4″ Diskette(s).
(iii) 3 1/2″ Diskette(s).
b. Apple Macintosh:
(i) Optical media, such as CD-ROM - best edition should adhere
to prevailing NISO standards.
(ii) 3 1/2″ Diskette(s).
IX. Electronic-Only Works Published in the United States and
Available Only Online
The following encodings are listed in descending order of
preference for all deposits in all categories below:
1. UTF-8.
2. UTF-16 (with BOM).
3. US-ASCII.
4. ISO 8859.
5. All other character encodings.
A. Electronic-Only Serials:
1. Content Format:
a. Serials-specific structured/markup format:
i. Content compliant with the NLM Journal Archiving (XML)
Document Type Definition (DTD), with presentation stylesheet(s),
rather than without NISO JATS: Journal Article Tag Suite (NISO
Z39.96-201x) with XSD/XSL presentation stylesheet(s) and explicitly
stated character encoding.
ii. Other widely used serials or journal XML DTDs/schemas, with
presentation stylesheet(s), rather than without.
iii. Proprietary XML format for serials or journals (with
documentation), with DTD/schema and presentation stylesheet(s),
rather than without.
b. Page-oriented rendition:
i. PDF/UA (Portable Document Format/Universal Accessibility;
compliant with ISO 14289-1).
ii. PDF/A (Portable Document Format/Archival; compliant with ISO
19005).
iii. PDF (Portable Document Format, with searchable text, rather
than without; highest quality available, with features such as
searchable text, embedded fonts, lossless compression, high
resolution images, device-independent specification of colorspace;
content tagging; includes document formats such as PDF/X).
c. Other structured or markup formats:
i. Widely-used serials or journal non-proprietary XML-based
DTDs/schemas with presentation stylesheet(s).
ii. Proprietary XML-based format for serials or journals (with
documentation) with DTD/schema and presentation stylesheet(s).
iii. XHTML or HTML, with DOCTYPE declaration and presentation
stylesheet(s).
iv. XML-based document formats (widely used and publicly
documented). With presentation stylesheets, if applicable. Includes
ODF (ISO/IEC 26300) and OOXML (ISO/IEC 29500).
d. PDF (web-optimized with searchable text).
e. Other formats:
i. Rich text format.
ii. Plain text.
iii. Widely-used proprietary word processing or page-layout
formats.
iv. Other text formats not listed here.
2. Metadata Elements: If included with published version of
work, descriptive data (metadata) as described below should
accompany the deposited material:
a. Title level metadata: serial or journal title, ISSN,
publisher, frequency, place of publication.
b. Article level metadata, as relevant/or applicable: volume(s),
number(s), issue dates(s), article title(s), article author(s),
article identifier (DOI, etc.).
c. With other descriptive metadata (e.g., subject heading(s),
descriptor(s), abstract(s)), rather than without.
3. Completeness:
a. All elements considered integral to the publication and
offered for sale or distribution must be deposited - e.g.,
articles, table(s) of contents, front matter, back matter, etc.
Includes all associated external files and fonts considered
integral to or necessary to view the work as published.
b. All updates, supplements, releases, and supersessions
published as part of the work and offered for sale or distribution
must be deposited and received in a regular and timely manner for
proper maintenance of the deposit.
4. Technological measures that control access to or use of the
work should be removed.
B. Electronic-Only Books:
1. Content Format:
a. Book-specific structured/markup format, i.e.,
XML-based markup formats, with included or accessible DTD/schema,
XSD/XSL presentation stylesheet(s), and explicitly stated character
encoding:
i. BITS-compliant (NLM Book DTD).
ii. EPUB-compliant.
iii. Other widely-used book DTD/schemas (e.g., TEI, DocBook,
etc.).
b. Page-oriented rendition:
i. PDF/UA (Portable Document Format/Universal Accessibility;
compliant with ISO 14289-1).
ii. PDF/A (Portable Document Format/Archival; compliant with ISO
19005).
ii. PDF (Portable Document Format; highest quality available,
with features such as searchable text, embedded fonts, lossless
compression, high resolution images, device-independent
specification of colorspace; content tagging; includes document
formats such as PDF/X).
c. Other structured markup formats:
i. XHTML or HTML, with DOCTYPE declaration and presentation
stylesheet(s).
ii. XML-based document formats (widely-used and
publicly-documented), with presentation style sheet(s) if
applicable. Includes ODF (ISO/IEC 26300) and OOXML (ISO/IEC
29500).
iii. SGML, with included or accessible DTD.
iv. Other XML-based non-proprietary formats, with presentation
stylesheet(s).
v. XML-based formats that use proprietary DTDs or schemas, with
presentation stylesheet(s).
d. PDF (web-optimized with searchable text).
e. Other formats:
i. Rich text format.
ii. Plain text.
iii. Widely-used proprietary word processing formats.
iv. Other text formats not listed here.
2. Metadata Elements: If included with published version of
work, descriptive data (metadata) as described below should
accompany the deposited material:
a. As supported by format (e.g., standards-based formats such as
ONIX, XMP, MODS, or MARCXML either embedded in or accompanying the
digital item): title, creator, creation date, place of publication,
publisher/producer/distributor, ISBN, contact information.
b. Include if part of published version of work: language of
work, other relevant identifiers (e.g., DOI, LCCN, etc.), edition,
subject descriptors, abstracts.
3. Rarity and Special Features:
a. Limited editions (including those with special features such
as high resolution images.)
b. Editions with the greatest number of unique features (such as
additional content, multimedia, interactive elements.)
4. Completeness:
a. For items published in a finite number of separate
components, all elements published as part of the work and offered
for sale or distribution must be deposited. Includes all associated
external files and fonts considered integral to or necessary to
view the work as published.
b. All updates, supplements, releases, and supersessions
published as part of the work and offered for sale or distribution
must be submitted and received in a regular and timely manner for
proper maintenance of the deposit.
5. Technological Protection Measures:
a. Copies published in formats that do not contain technological
measures controlling access to or use of the work.
b. Copies published with technological measures that control
access to or use of the work, and for which the owner has elected
to remove such technological measures.
c. Copies otherwise provided in a manner that meets the
requirements of § 202.24(a)(5).
X. Works Existing in More Than One Medium
Editions are listed below in descending order of preference.
A. Newspapers, dissertations and theses, newspaper-formatted
serials:
1. Microform.
2. Printed matter.
B. All other materials:
1. Printed matter.
2. Microform.
3. Phonorecord.
[54 FR 42299, Oct. 16, 1989, as amended at 62 FR 51603, Oct. 2,
1997; 69 FR 8822, Feb. 26, 2004; 75 FR 3869, Jan. 25, 2010; 82 FR
9362, Feb. 6, 2017; 83 FR 61550, Nov. 30, 2018; 85 FR 71837, Nov.
12, 2020]